Connect with an AgentA RE/MAX Bentley's expert will be in touch
Select your preferred date
Open Houses
Saturday, November 7, 2026
12:00 PM – 1:30 PM EST
Description
Fall in love with this irresistibly charming, west-facing Plum Island cottage—a treasured family retreat for decades and the sweetest setting for relaxed island living. The inviting front porch offers a front-row seat to Plum Island’s spectacular sunsets, while the basin is just steps away for launching a kayak or canoe. The ocean and sandy dune beach are only one street away. Inside, two full wal...
Fall in love with this irresistibly charming, west-facing Plum Island cottage—a treasured family retreat for decades and the sweetest setting for relaxed island living. The inviting front porch offers a front-row seat to Plum Island’s spectacular sunsets, while the basin is just steps away for launching a kayak or canoe. The ocean and sandy dune beach are only one street away. Inside, two full walls of windows fill the cheerful, open-concept L-shaped living & dining area with amazing natural light and create an inviting space for gathering after a day at the beach. The thoughtfully designed kitchen maximizes cabinet, pantry & dish storage, while three cozy bedrooms and a 3/4 bathroom with shower provide comfortable accommodations. All windows throughout the home are newer vinyl replacements. The property also offers private outdoor space, a storage shed and parking for six cars. The cottage is currently enjoyed seasonally, from approximately April through November. A newer ductless mini-split in the main living area provides heating & cooling but is not considered sufficient for the coldest winter months. The water heater is also newer. Former propane heating units have been disconnected and the propane tanks removed. A vintage plug-in washing machine remains in working condition; with clothesline space in the backyard. You will have an exciting array of possibilities: enjoy this delightful cottage just as it is, thoughtfully improve and update it for year-round living, or explore the potential to create an entirely new island home, much like the recently rebuilt contemporary residence next door. Any renovations, expansion or new construction would be subject to all applicable permitting and approvals. Lovingly held by the same family for generations, this enchanting island haven is now ready for you to begin living your dreams at the beach. Easy to show!
Plum Island Real Estate Cruising the Plum Island Turnpike feels like a vacation. As manicured lawns give way to marsh views and dune grass, sea breezes come from every direction.…
Listing Courtesy of Barb Cullen, Keller Williams Realty Evolution
The property listing data and information, or the Images, set forth herein were provided to MLS Property Information Network, Inc. from third party sources, including sellers, lessors, landlords and public records, and were compiled by MLS Property Information Network, Inc. The property listing data and information, and the Images, are for the personal, non commercial use of consumers having a good faith interest in purchasing, leasing or renting listed properties of the type displayed to them and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties which such consumers may have a good faith interest in purchasing, leasing or renting. MLS Property Information Network, Inc. and its subscribers disclaim any and all representations and warranties as to the accuracy of the property listing data and information, or as to the accuracy of any of the Images, set forth herein.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many bedrooms does 9 58th St in Newburyport have?
3 bedrooms.
How many bathrooms does 9 58th St have?
1 bathroom.
What is the square footage of 9 58th St?
1,020 sq ft.
When was 9 58th St built?
Built in 1950.
What is the lot size at 9 58th St?
0.1 acres (4,356 sq ft).
What type of property is 9 58th St?
Single Family Residence.
What neighborhood is 9 58th St in?
Plum Island, Newburyport.
What parking is available at 9 58th St?
6 parking spaces.
What are the annual property taxes for 9 58th St?
$5,107/year (2026).
What type of heating does 9 58th St have?
Ductless.
Does 9 58th St have air conditioning?
Yes — Ductless.
What utilities are available at 9 58th St?
Water/Sewer: Public / Public Sewer.
What is nearby 9 58th St?
Public Transportation, Shopping, Pool, Tennis Court(s), Park, Walk/Jog Trails.
What school district serves Newburyport, MA?
Newburyport Public Schools.
Connect with an AgentA RE/MAX Bentley's expert will be in touch